Hacker News 中文摘要

RSS订阅

Firefox是目前唯一仍支持uBlock Origin的主流浏览器 -- Firefox is now the last major browser that still supports uBlock Origin

文章摘要

Firefox成为唯一仍支持uBlock Origin的主流浏览器,其他浏览器因转向Manifest V3而限制广告拦截功能,用户若需高效广告拦截,Firefox是当前最佳选择。

文章总结

火狐浏览器近日宣布将继续支持uBlock Origin广告拦截扩展,这使其成为唯一仍支持该扩展的主流浏览器。此前,微软Edge等基于Chromium的浏览器因转向Manifest V3架构,将逐步淘汰uBlock Origin等基于Manifest V2的扩展。火狐因不基于Chromium,得以保持对uBlock Origin的支持,而其他非Chromium浏览器如Safari和DuckDuckGo也不支持该扩展。对于uBlock Origin的忠实用户,火狐成为无需妥协的选择,其他浏览器用户则只能使用功能较弱的uBlock Origin Lite或内置广告拦截功能。

评论总结

根据评论内容,主要围绕浏览器扩展(尤其是广告拦截器)的 Manifest v2 与 v3 之争展开,观点分化明显。以下是总结:

1. 支持 Firefox/Brave 等替代浏览器 - 多位用户认为 Firefox 和 Brave 是更好的选择,因其仍支持 Manifest v2 或内置广告拦截功能。 - 关键引用:
- "Thank God for the Brave browser... there is a Manifest v2 opt-out specifically for uBlock" (vovavili)
- "Firefox, after 20 years, once again has an advantage over the other browsers" (timetraveller26)
- "Firefox is also the only browser that vets uBlock's code on every update" (GeekyBear)

2. 对 Chrome/Edge 限制 Manifest v2 的批评 - 用户指责 Google 通过 Manifest v3 削弱扩展功能,认为这是对用户自由的限制。 - 关键引用:
- "extensions were supposed to be a way to let you do the things the browser didn't want you to do... they had to make a store with a gate, and destroy the APIs" (avaer)
- "Manifest 3 is why I finally shut down Sitetruth and Ad Limiter. Removing ads from Google Search is now possible only in Firefox" (Animats)

3. 对 Manifest v3 实际影响的质疑 - 部分用户认为 v3 影响不大,如 uBlock Origin Lite 仍能有效拦截广告。 - 关键引用:
- "Does it really make a huge difference to keep supporting Manifest Version 2? I've installed uBlock Origin Lite... I don't see any ads there either" (hn_submit)

4. 其他解决方案 - 用户提到可通过自定义扩展(如用 Claude 代码整合功能)或使用 Vivaldi 等浏览器绕过限制。 - 关键引用:
- "Anyone can build a custom extension... One extension to rule them all!" (spottedmarley)
- "Vivaldi 8.1 still supports it (Chromium 150) as loaded unpacked extension" (rasz)

总体趋势:多数评论倾向于支持 Firefox/Brave 等保留 Manifest v2 的浏览器,认为 Google 的限制损害了用户自主权,但也有少数用户认为 v3 影响有限。