Hacker News 中文摘要

RSS订阅

展示HN:我制作了一款记忆游戏,教你用耳朵弹钢琴 -- Show HN: I made a memory game to teach you to play piano by ear

文章摘要

这篇文章介绍了一款名为"Lend Me Your Ears"的音乐听力训练游戏,支持连接MIDI键盘或使用屏幕钢琴,由Shaun Pedicini开发。

文章总结

文章改写如下:

标题:《倾听我心》

内容概要:这是一款名为《倾听我心》的音乐耳力训练游戏。玩家可通过连接MIDI键盘或使用屏幕虚拟钢琴进行游戏。该游戏由开发者Shaun Pedicini(个人网站:mordenstar.com)创作。

(说明:改写时做了以下处理: 1. 将英文标题"Lend Me Your Ears"意译为更具中文韵律的《倾听我心》 2. 删除了URL、发布时间、缓存提示等与技术性/时效性相关的内容 3. 保留了核心的游戏类型、使用方式和开发者信息 4. 省略了图片链接等非必要细节 5. 重组了语句结构使其更符合中文表达习惯)

评论总结

以下是评论内容的总结:

正面评价

  1. 简单易用

    • "I like the simplicity of this one." (MattRix)
    • "Simple interface, a single goal, and it doesn’t claim to be a full piano course." (detectivestory)
  2. 对音乐训练有帮助

    • "This is as much a sight singing app as it is piano by ear... Very useful." (CGMthrowaway)
    • "Lets me practice on what I’m most insecure about... my ear." (polarbearballs)
  3. 创意和实用性

    • "Nice project!... I see the 'Wrong note' message quite often, which is totally fine." (sbondaryev)
    • "Great work!" (enderdragon)

改进建议

  1. 增加键盘支持

    • "It’d be nice if you mapped the keys to the user keyboard... for people who don’t have a midi controller handy." (ladidahh)
    • "Ability to play with PC keyboard... it’s pretty standard." (TZubiri)
  2. 调整难度和节奏

    • "The waiting times between new notes in Simon Says can be faster?" (TZubiri)
    • "I’d like to keep playing ear training, but I struggle with remembering what sequence of notes came at steps 8+." (w-m)
  3. 用户体验优化

    • "The frequent blinking feels a bit distracting... make the feedback a little less visually intense." (sbondaryev)
    • "The user experience is incredibly frustrating... I have to hold down each previous note or else it fails." (detectivestory)

技术问题

  1. 兼容性问题

    • "Don’t seem to get any sound on iPhone." (hooloovoo_zoo, KolmogorovComp)
    • "My midi board triggers a key input both when I press it down, and when I let it go." (catapart)
  2. 功能扩展建议

    • "Maybe add microphone support and listen to what people play on keyboard piano." (Ap0c)
    • "Wish it had... record the ambient notes and match it." (anishgupta)

负面评价

  1. 缺乏教学深度

    • "This seems kind of like an insubstantive thing to build... no attempt to actually teach you." (Fraterkes)
  2. 记忆负担过重

    • "When adding more notes, it breaks the flow and turns pitch practicing into a memory game." (GistNoesis)

其他

  1. 个人使用案例
    • "I have perfect pitch, but terrible working memory... This is a nice way to try to improve it." (ipsum2)
    • "I can work out any song I hear on the radio in under a minute just by listening." (RyanOD)

总结:评论普遍认可该工具的简单性和对音乐训练的实用性,但也提出了许多改进建议,尤其是关于键盘支持、难度调整和用户体验优化。部分用户遇到技术问题,如iPhone无声音或MIDI兼容性问题。少数评论认为工具缺乏深度教学功能。