Hacker News 中文摘要

RSS订阅

苏黎世市民投票禁止噪音扰民的吹叶机 -- Zürich voters ban noisy leaf blowers

文章摘要

苏黎世市民投票决定禁止使用噪音大的燃油动力吹叶机,以减少环境噪音污染。

文章总结

苏黎世市民投票禁止噪音扰民的汽油动力吹叶机

2025年9月28日,苏黎世市民以61.7%的多数票通过禁令,全面禁止使用汽油动力吹叶机。该禁令同时规定,电动吹叶机仅允许在每年10月至12月期间使用,其他月份仅限特殊情况(如街头游行后的街道清洁)方可使用。这项新规将同时适用于私人和市政工作人员。

此次公投源于议会党派团体对市议会禁令决定的质疑,他们认为这是"禁令文化的体现"。事实上,苏黎世市民反对吹叶机的斗争已持续多年:2013年绿党就曾提交4329人联署的请愿书;2022年绿党与社会民主党再次提交了相关动议。

投票结果显示,75248人支持修订警察条例,46717人反对,投票率为52.8%。这标志着苏黎世在解决噪音污染问题上迈出了重要一步。

(注:原文中大量导航菜单、相关新闻推荐、社交媒体链接等非核心内容已省略,重点保留了禁令内容、投票数据及历史背景等关键信息。)

评论总结

这篇评论主要围绕城市噪音污染和环境保护展开讨论,观点多样且具有争议性。以下是主要观点总结:

支持禁止噪音污染的观点: 1. 支持禁止高噪音设备(如吹叶机、摩托车): - "Cool, now do loud motorbikes in cities. Those things, several times louder than cars, should be illegal anywhere but on isolated highways."(pferde) - "The problem is not just the noise. It's also the fine dust concentration."(BSDobelix)

  1. 支持限制使用时间:
    • "Seems like one compromise would be that they can only be used during a few-hour period every other week or so."(gblargg)
    • "I wish there existed a law that defined a single three-hour or so window of time on Saturday during which you could mow your lawn..."(WesolyKubeczek)

反对过度限制的观点: 1. 认为过度限制影响生活便利性: - "If you want to live in nature and in a city you need the tools to manage it. Cutting the trees down is also a valid solution."(NedF) - "It's the classic arsehole world we have become, people have to be indignant about everything."(NedF)

  1. 提倡文明解决问题而非立法禁止:
    • "It would be nice if we could solve our problems in a nice and civil way, and to be considerate to one another instead of making things illegal."(4gotunameagain)

其他相关讨论: 1. 吹叶机的实用性争议: - "honestly i don't get the point of leaf blowers, you move the leaves with an extremely loud gasoline powered machine from one place to another"(thousand_nights) - "I have never understood leafblowing. It seems like such busy work."(nopelynopington)

  1. 噪音污染的其他来源:

    • "Now ban loud and aggressive dogs. 99.999% of dogs are good and quiet..."(throw93949494u7)
    • "Maybe it’s just me but I wonder why western countries don’t implement noise limits for vehicles with sirens in residential areas..."(tasoeur)
  2. 环境与健康影响:

    • "Letting your landscapers blow nutrients off your property is insane when it's difficult to find good quality top soil."(bob1029)
  3. 直接民主的积极评价:

    • "I love direct democracy."(Gud)

总结来看,评论者普遍关注城市噪音污染问题,但对解决方案存在分歧。支持者强调环境和健康影响,反对者则认为过度限制影响生活便利性。讨论还涉及其他噪音源(如摩托车、警报器)和吹叶机的实用性争议。