Hacker News 中文摘要

RSS订阅

Show HN:皮肤科医生打造皮肤癌学习应用 -- Show HN: I'm a dermatologist and I vibe coded a skin cancer learning app

文章摘要

molecheck.info提供了一个皮肤病变测验,用户可以通过手机扫描二维码或直接在桌面端参与。测验展示皮肤病变图片,用户需判断是否担忧,并可通过按钮或滑动操作进行选择。测验旨在帮助用户识别皮肤癌迹象,并提供相关信息和重置评分功能。

文章总结

标题:molecheck.info - 皮肤病变测验

主要内容:

molecheck.info 提供了一个专为移动设备设计的皮肤病变测验应用。用户可以通过扫描二维码在手机上获得最佳体验,也可以选择在桌面端继续使用。测验中,用户会看到一张皮肤病变的医学图像,并需要判断是否对此病变感到担忧。用户可以通过滑动或点击按钮(“我担忧”、“我不担忧”、“我不确定”)来表达自己的判断,并可以查看下一张图像。测验还提供了关于如何识别皮肤癌的链接,以及重置分数的选项。图像由联邦大学圣埃斯皮里图(UFES)提供,并遵循CC-BY许可。

评论总结

评论内容总结:

  1. 游戏体验与学习效果

    • 一些用户认为游戏有助于学习皮肤癌知识,但部分人觉得难度较大,正确率低,甚至可能引发不必要的担忧。
      • "I went from 50% to 85% very quickly. And that’s because most of them are skin cancer and that was easy to learn." (jjallen)
      • "My correct rate was under chance. This could be hypochondria inducing for many?" (jampekka)
  2. 图像与界面问题

    • 部分用户提到图像在移动设备上显示异常,且界面设计有待改进,如缩放功能不够实用。
      • "Why do the images get a weird offset slice effect on safari on mobile after submitting a guess with the buttons?" (leetrout)
      • "The zoomed in view is great if you’re commonly examining under magnification, but perhaps a slightly less zoomed view might make this more practical for common folks." (minton)
  3. AI与技术的应用

    • 用户对AI技术的应用表示赞赏,认为这是一个有潜力的教育工具,但也有人指出其局限性,如缺乏详细的决策过程解释。
      • "This is awesome. Great use of AI to realize an idea." (DrewADesign)
      • "I wish it also explained the decision making process, how to understand from the picture what is the right answer." (vindex10)
  4. 内容与数据的准确性

    • 用户希望游戏能更贴近实际发病率,并增加更多非癌症案例,以提高实用性。
      • "So my only advice would be to make closer to 50% actually skin cancer." (jjallen)
      • "Are there an equal amount of cancer and non cancer images? In my case the vast majority (I’d say around 75%) are cancerous." (redox99)
  5. 潜在的法律与伦理问题

    • 有用户提到可能的法律风险,如误诊导致的诉讼问题。
      • "Can people sue you for malpractice if something goes wrong?" (nextworddev)
  6. 未来改进建议

    • 用户建议增加更多功能,如尺寸标注、样本采集工具等,以提高诊断的准确性。
      • "If you can find sources with rulers or some kind of scale, that would be very helpful." (andreasgl)
      • "Would a tool that can take a truly tiny sample out of the lesion be a valuable complement?" (childintime)

总结:评论中既有对游戏教育价值的肯定,也有对技术局限性和用户体验的批评。用户普遍希望游戏能更贴近实际,增加更多实用功能,并解决现有的技术问题。